Choosing Your First Spyderco: Sage 5 vs. Paramilitary 2
By Logan M. Fraser – Custom Knife Modder & Spyderco Parts Specialist, Based in Calgary, Alberta, Canada
This is the 5th blog of the Knife blog series. You can check the other blogs I’ve written here: https://spymodz.com/blogs
Choosing your first Spyderco knife can be overwhelming—especially when you’re torn between two fan favorites: the Sage 5 and the Paramilitary 2 (PM2). Both knives represent the best of what Spyderco has to offer, but which one is the better fit for your first serious carry?
As someone who modifies and services both models regularly, I’ll walk you through a hands-on comparison to help you decide.
Overview of the Contenders 
Spyderco Sage 5
Blade Length: 3.00″
Lock Type: Compression Lock
Handle: Carbon Fiber/G10 laminate or FRN
Weight: Approx. 3.2 oz
The Sage 5 is compact, lightweight, and a bit more refined in terms of everyday utility.
Spyderco Paramilitary 2
Blade Length: 3.44″
Lock Type: Compression Lock
Handle: G10
Weight: Approx. 3.9 oz
The PM2 is larger, more rugged, and built for hard-use scenarios.
Ergonomics & Carry Comfort 
Sage 5 has a sleeker profile that disappears in the pocket. It’s more EDC-friendly if you’re in and out of an office or casual environment.
PM2 offers a more pronounced finger choil and textured grip for aggressive tasks. It might feel bulky in lightweight pants, but excels in hand during extended cutting.
Blade Performance 
Both knives are slicers, but the PM2 has a longer reach and slightly thicker stock, making it more versatile for outdoor or utility use. The Sage 5, with its shorter blade, offers more control for precise cuts and food prep.
Lock Mechanism 
They both feature Spyderco’s Compression Lock—one of the most popular and robust lock designs in the industry. That means smooth one-handed closing and rock-solid lock-up.
However, PM2s often have smoother deployment out of the box, while Sage 5s may require a brief break-in period.
Modding Potential 
As someone who specializes in Spyderco mods, I can tell you:
PM2 is modding heaven. Tons of aftermarket support for scales, hardware, backspacers, and more.
Sage 5 has fewer third-party options, but you can still upgrade scales and clips fairly easily.
Looking for compatible upgrades? You can browse real-fit hardware and custom parts at https://spymodz.com, where every piece is tested for fitment on authentic models.
Price & Availability 
The Sage 5 is often priced a bit lower than the PM2, depending on the version (FRN being more affordable). If budget is a major factor, Sage 5 gives you a lot of value for the money.
That said, the PM2’s cult status keeps it in high demand—and for good reason. It’s built to last.
What the Community Says 
On forums like Spyderco Forum and BladeForums, the PM2 gets top praise for toughness and mod potential.
The Sage 5 earns love for its classier, more compact design that still delivers Spyderco-level performance.
Both knives have loyal followings—it really comes down to use case.
My Recommendation 
Go with the Sage 5 if you want a refined, lighter EDC with solid performance.
Pick the PM2 if you prefer a larger blade, customization options, and a knife that can take a beating.
Either way, you’re not making a bad choice—both knives are backed by decades of Spyderco experience and are built to serve you well.
Final Thoughts 
Choosing between the Spyderco Sage 5 and Paramilitary 2 isn’t easy—but it’s a good problem to have. Both are outstanding knives with unique strengths.
Still undecided? Drop your thoughts or questions in the comment section below. And let me know what knife topic you’d like me to cover in next week’s Knife Blog Series.